patching...
Update: New! Tune in to WPIX11 at 5 p.m. to see Patch's Top Stories from the tri-state area.
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Holocaust Survivor to Students: 'Never Say Never'

A Holocaust survivor tells BOCES students stories of his adventures and tragic losses during the war.

 

Students can learn about history from textbooks and their teachers, but nothing compares to the eyewitness account one man shared with Putnam-Northern Westchester BOCES students on Friday.

"It's not an easy subject," said Stephen M. Berger, a Holocaust survivor who was born in Hungary and currently lives in Floral Park. "A difficult subject, but part of history and history is so important. We can learn so much from it."

Berger said it was luck that spared his own life and the life of his mother and younger sister during the time he spent under the Nazi occupation. From deciding to get on the first deportation train, which was not bound for Auschwitz, to having a civilian intervene when he was almost shot by an SS officer. 

Right before the liberation, he said he took a chance to hide with his mother and sister in a basement. But a German soldier came knocking at the door, so he was sure they'd be discovered. Nothing happened. As he went up to the door, Berger saw a Russian soldier and knew they were free.  

"My friends, you don't know how freedom feels until you lose it," he told the audience. 

After the liberation by Allied Forces, Berger briefly returned to Hungary. His parents and sister survived, but upon his return he found out 26 members of his immediate family were killed by the Germans and Hungarian Nazi collaborators.

"How did I keep my faith alive?" Berger responded when asked the question by a student. "Because I knew I was right, and they were wrong. I never doubted myself."

Berger, who said he has lost count of how many times he has told he story, is more concerned that once he is gone, there won't be anyone to tell it. 

"I worry about it a lot," he said. "The Holocaust isn't unique in human history and genocides are happening even today while we speak. Of course now it's not the Jews, it's the Christians' turn now."

He said more than 100,000 African Christians were killed in the last two years, Berger said. He asked students if they knew about it and a few hands went up. 

He said people need to study history and often the next generations of victims are those who have neglected to do so. He said many had missed the warning signs of the Holocaust, which he called industrialized mass murder by the 20th century’s barbarians, in the middle of a "so-called cultured" Europe. He referenced Pearl Harbor and the Twin Towers as other atrocities aimed at a specific group of people.

Berger, 85, was born in Debrecen, Hungary and got his education at local Jewish schools. He enjoyed reading books, citing Mark Twain as one of his favorite authors, and collected books into his own personal collection.

His whole life changed in 1944 when he was 16 and still in high school. The Nazi army moved into his city. They closed all schools, didn't let the Jews use public transportation, took away their radios and bikes, didn't let them to go to the library and forced them to wear the yellow Star of David in public for identification purposes. They also forced them into the ghetto, which was too small to fit everyone whom they brought. 

"But we as a community, always did the best we could," Berger said. 

He said he knew the Nazis were burning books, so in thinking how he could save his book collection, Berger out them all in a big box and buried them in the ground, thinking that when he comes back to his town, he'll get them back.

"You don't know what the future will bring," he said. 

He told stories of how a week after they were brought to the ghetto, their food ran out. He and two of his friends were able to jump over the fence, buy food and return to the ghetto. He described how he was forced to pull bodies out of the rubble and put them into a makeshift morgue. His mother fainted when she saw him covered in blood that night, he said. 

He spared students the gruesome details of what went on at a brickyard before he and others were crammed into cattle cars. 

"I'm not going to describe the situation at this brickyard," he told the audience. "Because I want you to sleep at night."

Later Berger and about 100 others from the ghetto were packed into trains and locked for three-and-a-half days, surrounded by the elderly, sick, women and children, as they were transported to the concentration camp Strasshof in Germany. Inside, there was no room to sit, or move and no food or water. Several people committed suicide on the train, while others tumbled over when they were let out. 

Before he was sent to a slave camp in Austria as a mechanic, he was nearly shot by an SS officer because he refused to leave without his mother and sister, but was saved by a civilian's intervention. 

"You work until you have enough energy to work," he said as he described the camp. "When you have no more energy, you're eliminated."

He described the small portions of food they were given and the constant hunger they lived with in a world where food meant survival. Toward the end of the war, he was given a sandwich by a main and food by the mother of a German soldier.

Little details were left out as Berger described the gas chambers: how people were told to undress, and that they would take showers, only to see poison coming from the hatches on top of the roof where German soldiers wore gas masks. Mothers held their babies and young children above them in hopes of giving them a few more seconds of life, as gas rose from bottom to top. 

"It took less than two minutes to kill innocent people," he said. 

Berger captivated students with his incredible stories of courage and survival. His message was not one of pain and suffering, but rather one of remembering what happened and to never forget because history could repeat itself.

"Nothing changes in this world," he told the audience. "Only people and places change."

He often called himself "lucky" to be alive and in many of his stories, despite tragic losses and excruciating circumstances, he would tell his mother that they've made it so far and were lucky to be alive.

"So much to tell and always not enough time," Berger told students.

After the liberation, Berger joined the Zionist movement, left Hungary, worked for the emigration of European Jews to Palestine and contributed to Israel’s war for independence.

At the end of his presentation, Berger took questions from the students and showed them a picture of a cattle car and his fourth-grade graduation picture. One student shed tears as she shook his hand, clearly moved by his stories. 

"I think he is a very brave man," 17-year-old Gennaro Zinganoe of Cortlandt Manor said. "And with all the things he went through, not to lose his spirit."

Gennaro said although he had known about the Holocaust, the one part of Berger's stories that stood out was the fact that he didn't think it was possible for someone to sneak out of the camps, as Berger did, and get away with it. 

Lonie Nugent, a 17-year-old student from Mount Kisco, said Berger had "lucky breaks" and enjoyed listening to his stories. 

"He had a more in-depth view because of his age and his fortunate outcome," Lonie said of Berger. 

As far as Berger, he said his wish is that the next generations remember what happened during the Holocaust and that it could happen again if people don't learn lessons from history. 

"I'll never say never," he said. 

Currently Berger is a member of the Queensborough Community College Holocaust Resource Center Speakers Bureau and Holocaust Memorial and Tolerance Center of Nassau County.

__

Thank you for reading! You can "like" Yorktown Patch on Facebook and follow our Tweets.

Related Topics: Holocaust and Stephen Berger

Jenny

4:47 pm on Saturday, January 14, 2012

This is a fantastic idea! Having people who actually went thru the experience is wonderful for the kids to experience. When I went to Yorktown HS I remember they showed real movies taken during the Holocaust. People dead or walking skeletons. It was profound. To have kids see that PLUS talk to this man, would be ideal. Telling the kids that instead of coming to school tomorrow you were told no more school and held prisioner till they shipped you to the Nazi prison. To have them experience what did, and could happen again. We don't have many more years of people who experienced this first hand. Please take advantage of men like this while we can. God bless him and his kindness for sharing such a life story. I hope he does this again and again...

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Katie Ryan O'Connor

11:48 am on Sunday, January 15, 2012

Thank you for commenting Jenny. I experienced the same kind of presentation in the late 1980s as a high school student in Rochester, NY and I have never forgotten it. Personal stories can be so powerful.

eve

8:52 pm on Saturday, January 14, 2012

Have those students look at David Duke's website to see how similar his anti-Semitic and racist rants are to the Nazi propaganda, especially the fabricated statistics. His followers are told (with bogus US Justice Department stats) that in 2005 over 30,000 rapes were committed by Blacks against white women, while white men did not rape one white woman. That fake statistic is then extrapolated into a battle cry telling whites that they must arm themselves against Blacks. David Duke has a following - the numbers have grown since the election of Barack Obama. His anti-Semitic message is also fueled by fabricated statistics. Those who believe there can never be a Holocaust or race war in this country are naive because of the complacency of most Americans.

Reply
Comment_arrow

elizabeth mclaughlin

4:51 pm on Sunday, January 15, 2012

I agree, many should do a search on UN Agenda 21, already the city is in compliance and Westchester County under the guise of sustainable, environment, councils, and
ICLEI programs. They do have a web site and Westchester County is listed. Your Town, County are using it. With all of the censorship on major media networks, erc. for years in the makings we are now faced with economic and social genocide. Please do a search on those topics. We should be listening to Mr. Berger and sharing this article everywhere.

John Q. Public

10:08 pm on Saturday, January 14, 2012

Strange this guy doesn't mention the Shoah Foundation's excellent documentary "The Last Days" or Elie Wiesel.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jenny

11:19 am on Sunday, January 15, 2012

Why should he mention the Shoah Foundation? He was relaying his experience. And besides, were you there? We don't know everything he discussed. The video was short. I would love to hear his whole presentation. These kids are lucky to have him. I only hope he continues to educate people with his story. So many Holocaust survivors are so old now. We are lucky to have them for as long as possible to educated those who need to hear this first hand.

elizabeth mclaughlin

1:38 pm on Sunday, January 15, 2012

Thank you for publishing this story. Everyone should not forget the Holocaust. My father was in the war and tore down a gatekeepers flag at a camp. He drove a tank. It is also very sad that we are seeing the truth behind the war too with the current surge of communism throughout the world and our own country. I will not support UN Agenda 21, ICLEI programs, funding, stimulous. It is quite shocking that this movement disguises itself under sustainable, environment. And, that a natural post glacial rebound, isotonic adjustment is timely used for penetrating world governments. I thank this man for coming up and speaking about his experience and everyone should not forget it.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jenny

4:04 pm on Sunday, January 15, 2012

My father was a bomber pilot bombing Germany in WW2. He has pictures from above of the camps, and he said at the time they didn't know what they were.

elizabeth mclaughlin

2:06 pm on Sunday, January 15, 2012

I do not know if BOCES offers courses for people to learn the Constitution but it may be a good idea. It is also important for people to support their County Constitutional Sheriff.

Reply

Jenny

4:03 pm on Sunday, January 15, 2012

Why are they only having this man speak at BOCES? I thought it was at the main HS in Yorktown? He should speak to every grade level in HS. I know that might be a bit much for him at his age, but he needs to speak at least to the Seniors at the HS. I graduated from YHS in 76 and I think we were shown those shocking movies in 10th grade. This should be done as well. Classes like this should be more common, not rare.

Reply
Comment_arrow

elizabeth mclaughlin

4:52 pm on Sunday, January 15, 2012

They should have him speak at the High School, history class as a guest speaker.

jennifer carpenter low

1:25 pm on Saturday, January 21, 2012

The Holocaust Memorial and Tolerance Center of Nassau County could not operate at the world-class level that it does without the commitment of volunteer educators, Holocaust Survivors and Liberators and our committed Board of Directors who have steered the Center in exciting new directions in programming and outreach. Survivors' and Liberators' eye-witness testimony adds efficacy to our work with young people. And, our educational volunteers demonstrate the meaning of being an Upstander. We are so grateful to Stephen Berger and many others who enable the Center to offer enriching programs that build a better world for our children.
Jennifer Carpenter Low, Holocaust Memorial and Tolerance Center
www.holocaust-nassau.org

Reply

Leave a comment