Update: State Court Rules MTA Payroll Tax is Unconstitutional

Transit agency says it will fight ruling.

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority says it is going to fight a Wednesday state court decision that ruled the enacted to bolster the agency's budget is unconstitutional.

However, the ruling by state Supreme Court Judge R. Bruce Cozzens Jr. in Nassau County quickly recieved cheers from government officials in the counties affected by the payroll tax, including Westchester, Rockland and Putnam.

“This is good news for Westchester County and its municipalities," said Westchester County Executive Robert P. Astorino. "The MTA payroll tax is essentially an unfunded mandate from Albany. In this case, we were allowed to challenge it. We did. And now we’ve won an important victory with the court’s decision that this unfair burden on taxpayers was unconstitutional.”

The tax was also vehemently opposed by Rockland County Executive C. Scott Vanderhoef, who argued the tax hit Rockland especially hard. In addition to creating a new tax for employers, Vanderhoef argued the tax broadened the gap between what Rockland pays to the MTA and the transit services it gets back from the agency.

“The Payroll Tax is one of the insidious ‘hidden taxes’ that have made the public mistrust the state government,” Vanderhoef said. “It places an unfair, job-stifling burden on businesses that receive little if any benefit from the MTA. The Payroll Tax is little more than a shift of hard-earned money from suburban business owners and employees to New York City. It is another unfunded burden from the state on our taxpayers.”

Vanderhoef contends the MTA should address its "out-of-control spending and inflated overtime costs," not impose rising fees and taxes on the region’s residents and businesses.

“The MTA is supposed to be a public service, not a public burden,” Vanderhoef said.

Cozzens found in his decision that the payroll tax was not properly enacted by the state Legislature in 2009. The tax was created to cover a massive budget deficit at the MTA.

The tax was opposed by county and local officials, who criticized it for adding a new layer of taxes at a time when local economies could least afford the additional burden.

Wednesday's ruling, however, did not come with an order to halt tax collections.

Assemblyman  (D-Rye), said the elimination of the MTA Payroll Tax would directly help Westchester taxpayers. 

"Under Gov. (Andrew) Cuomo’s leadership, we were able to eliminate the mobility tax for 25,000 small businesses in Westchester alone and now that the MTA has begun to stabilize its finances by controlling costs rather then balancing the books on the backs of suburban taxpayers, we can deliver real relief to Westchester residents," Latimer said. "I hope that with this new ruling we will be able to finally pass the legislation that I have introduced that fully repeal the MTA Payroll Tax.”

Latimer's opponent in the upcoming election for state Senate, , R-New Rochelle, also applauded the court decision. But he was quick to place part of the blame for the creation of the payroll tax on Latimer

"This is great news for Westchester small businesses and other entities that have been unfairly burdened by this unconstitutional tax," Cohen said. "This tax was passed by short-sighted Albany politicians, including my opponent George Latimer, who think new and higher taxes are the answer to every problem. This MTA payroll tax has cost Westchester businesses millions of dollars and an untold number of jobs. Mr. Latimer's tax has been ridden out of town on a rail."

New York State Senator Greg Ball (R, C — Patterson), said after the ruling, "Since this tax was created, I have been fighting for a full repeal, and this ruling will allow us to make our 80 percent repeal a full repeal and on an expedited time frame. I am so happy to hear that this job-killing tax was ruled unconstitutional, and now its time to demand a full repeal as well as a retroactive refund! I will be working with my colleagues in the legislature along with the Governor to expedite this process and finally repeal this horrific tax, the vampire of all taxes, for good."

Aidan August 25, 2012 at 11:31 AM
NY liberals have created this mess ... and most others. Get smart for once.
Billy August 25, 2012 at 12:34 PM
Sty, you're really going back into ancient history w/some of your facts which is why I like to keep it in the present & in the present state of NY, everyone needs and should want a balanced government and you don't get that with 1 party control which is what would happen if the Democrats took control of the senate. Open your eyes & ears for once & enlighten yourself. The state can't afford to buy eveything. The state can only buy what the state can afford and someone needs to look out for the little guy/gal to make sure the state isn't making it unaffordable but affordable to live in said state. That means we need jobs & economic expansion & lower taxes. George's voting record suggests that he doesn't support this agenda. I do know he also runs on the Working Families Party line, isn't that the party set up by the state unions to keep their power? Maybe you could give me a history lesson on the WFP? I know he also didn't vote at all on the pension reform bill last spring so he seems to favor the state worker and not the people paying the state workers salary.
Watchdog August 25, 2012 at 12:48 PM
Heres a better idea. Don't vote for the Libs. Figure it out. Think.
Bart Didden August 27, 2012 at 12:55 PM
Based on the overflowing number of liberals we have as Judges here in NYS, I don't believe this decision will survive an appeal.
jo August 27, 2012 at 03:10 PM
dump the dems ... all of them...


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »